{ "angle": "French lighthouse identity is traced through three cases where the signal outlives the material tower, the original optical apparatus, or the keeper regime: La Coubre, Ar-Men, and Cordouan.", "claims": [ { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "archive", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "alternate_name", "field_label": "Alternate name", "id": "CLAIM-LUX-LH-000249-alternate_name-001", "payload": { "confidence": "archive", "raw_value": "Пти Мину", "source_field": "multi_fields.lighthouse_name_aka.field_lighthouse_name_aka_value", "value": "Пти Мину" }, "raw_value": "Пти Мину", "record_status": "current", "review_status": "current", "source_field": "multi_fields.lighthouse_name_aka.field_lighthouse_name_aka_value", "source_id": "node:935", "source_nid": 935, "source_note": "Derived from multi_fields.lighthouse_name_aka.field_lighthouse_name_aka_value", "source_title": "Petit Minou", "source_type": "migration_field", "source_url": "/node/935", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": "Пти Мину" }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "derived", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "location_taxonomy", "field_label": "Location taxonomy", "id": "CLAIM-LUX-LH-000249-location_taxonomy-001", "payload": { "confidence": "derived", "raw_value": { "name": "самые красивые", "parent_tid": 0, "path": [ 215 ], "path_names": [ "самые красивые" ], "tid": 215, "vid": 6, "vocabulary": "Звания и отличия" }, "source_field": "taxonomy", "value": "самые красивые" }, "raw_value": { "name": "самые красивые", "parent_tid": 0, "path": [ 215 ], "path_names": [ "самые красивые" ], "tid": 215, "vid": 6, "vocabulary": "Звания и отличия" }, "record_status": "current", "review_status": "current", "source_field": "taxonomy", "source_id": "node:935", "source_nid": 935, "source_note": "Derived from taxonomy", "source_title": "Petit Minou", "source_type": "migration_field", "source_url": "/node/935", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": "самые красивые" }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "derived", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "location_taxonomy", "field_label": "Location taxonomy", "id": "CLAIM-LUX-LH-000249-location_taxonomy-002", "payload": { "confidence": "derived", "raw_value": { "name": "Франция", "parent_tid": 0, "path": [ 233 ], "path_names": [ "Франция" ], "tid": 233, "vid": 9, "vocabulary": "Страна" }, "source_field": "taxonomy", "value": "Франция" }, "raw_value": { "name": "Франция", "parent_tid": 0, "path": [ 233 ], "path_names": [ "Франция" ], "tid": 233, "vid": 9, "vocabulary": "Страна" }, "record_status": "current", "review_status": "current", "source_field": "taxonomy", "source_id": "node:935", "source_nid": 935, "source_note": "Derived from taxonomy", "source_title": "Petit Minou", "source_type": "migration_field", "source_url": "/node/935", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": "Франция" }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "archive", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "media", "field_label": "Media reference", "id": "CLAIM-LUX-LH-000249-media-001", "payload": { "confidence": "archive", "raw_value": 1018, "source_field": "multi_fields.lh_foto.field_lh_foto_fid", "value": 1018 }, "raw_value": 1018, "record_status": "current", "review_status": "current", "source_field": "multi_fields.lh_foto.field_lh_foto_fid", "source_id": "node:935", "source_nid": 935, "source_note": "Derived from multi_fields.lh_foto.field_lh_foto_fid", "source_title": "Petit Minou", "source_type": "migration_field", "source_url": "/node/935", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": 1018 }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "archive", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "media", "field_label": "Media reference", "id": "CLAIM-LUX-LH-000249-media-002", "payload": { "confidence": "archive", "raw_value": 1019, "source_field": "multi_fields.pic_dop.field_pic_dop_fid", "value": 1019 }, "raw_value": 1019, "record_status": "current", "review_status": "current", "source_field": "multi_fields.pic_dop.field_pic_dop_fid", "source_id": "node:935", "source_nid": 935, "source_note": "Derived from multi_fields.pic_dop.field_pic_dop_fid", "source_title": "Petit Minou", "source_type": "migration_field", "source_url": "/node/935", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": 1019 }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "archive", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "source_link", "field_label": "Source link", "id": "CLAIM-LUX-LH-000249-source_link-001", "payload": { "confidence": "archive", "raw_value": "http://alp.org.ua", "source_field": "multi_fields.dop_description.field_dop_description_url", "value": "http://alp.org.ua" }, "raw_value": "http://alp.org.ua", "record_status": "current", "review_status": "current", "source_field": "multi_fields.dop_description.field_dop_description_url", "source_id": "node:935", "source_nid": 935, "source_note": "Derived from multi_fields.dop_description.field_dop_description_url", "source_title": "Petit Minou", "source_type": "migration_field", "source_url": "/node/935", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": "http://alp.org.ua" }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "high", "date_precision": "year-range", "field_id": "construction_date", "field_label": "Construction period", "id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000042", "payload": { "claim_id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000042", "confidence": "high", "date_precision": "year-range", "field_id": "construction_date", "field_label": "Construction period", "raw_value": "Construction period recorded for Ar-Men.", "review_status": "accepted", "source_evidence": [ { "evidence_note": "French Ministry of Culture heritage record for Ar-Men.", "source_id": "pop:IA29000456", "source_label": "Phare d'Ar-Men - POP / Mérimée", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://pop.culture.gouv.fr/notice/merimee/IA29000456" } ], "source_id": "pop:IA29000456", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "Construction-period claim for Ar-Men prepared from the French Ministry of Culture POP/Mérimée record.", "source_title": "Phare d'Ar-Men - POP / Mérimée", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://pop.culture.gouv.fr/notice/merimee/IA29000456", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "1867", "valid_to": "1881", "value": "1867-1881" }, "raw_value": "Construction period recorded for Ar-Men.", "record_status": "accepted", "review_status": "accepted", "source_id": "pop:IA29000456", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "Construction-period claim for Ar-Men prepared from the French Ministry of Culture POP/Mérimée record.", "source_quote": "", "source_title": "Phare d'Ar-Men - POP / Mérimée", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://pop.culture.gouv.fr/notice/merimee/IA29000456", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "unit": "", "valid_from": "1867", "valid_to": "1881", "value": "1867-1881" }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "high", "date_precision": "year", "field_id": "first_lit_date", "field_label": "First lit date", "id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000043", "payload": { "claim_id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000043", "confidence": "high", "date_precision": "year", "field_id": "first_lit_date", "field_label": "First lit date", "raw_value": "First lit / mise en service year recorded for Ar-Men.", "review_status": "accepted", "source_evidence": [ { "evidence_note": "French Ministry of Culture heritage record for Ar-Men.", "source_id": "pop:IA29000456", "source_label": "Phare d'Ar-Men - POP / Mérimée", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://pop.culture.gouv.fr/notice/merimee/IA29000456" } ], "source_id": "pop:IA29000456", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "First-light year prepared from the French Ministry of Culture POP/Mérimée record.", "source_title": "Phare d'Ar-Men - POP / Mérimée", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://pop.culture.gouv.fr/notice/merimee/IA29000456", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "1881", "valid_to": "", "value": "1881" }, "raw_value": "First lit / mise en service year recorded for Ar-Men.", "record_status": "accepted", "review_status": "accepted", "source_id": "pop:IA29000456", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "First-light year prepared from the French Ministry of Culture POP/Mérimée record.", "source_quote": "", "source_title": "Phare d'Ar-Men - POP / Mérimée", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://pop.culture.gouv.fr/notice/merimee/IA29000456", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "unit": "", "valid_from": "1881", "valid_to": "", "value": "1881" }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "medium", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "light_characteristic", "field_label": "Light characteristic", "id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000044", "payload": { "claim_id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000044", "confidence": "medium", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "light_characteristic", "field_label": "Light characteristic", "raw_value": "Current light characteristic from official lights listing; verify exact edition during nautical QA.", "review_status": "accepted", "source_evidence": [ { "evidence_note": "Official French sea-lights listing used as current navigation-light reference.", "source_id": "dirm:livre-des-feux:ar-men", "source_label": "Livre des Feux - Ar-Men", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://www.dirm.nord-atlantique-manche-ouest.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/livre-des-feux-r402.html" } ], "source_id": "dirm:livre-des-feux:ar-men", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "Current light-characteristic claim sourced to the official Livre des Feux reference page.", "source_title": "Livre des Feux - Ar-Men", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://www.dirm.nord-atlantique-manche-ouest.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/livre-des-feux-r402.html", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": "Fl(3) W 20s" }, "raw_value": "Current light characteristic from official lights listing; verify exact edition during nautical QA.", "record_status": "accepted", "review_status": "accepted", "source_id": "dirm:livre-des-feux:ar-men", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "Current light-characteristic claim sourced to the official Livre des Feux reference page.", "source_quote": "", "source_title": "Livre des Feux - Ar-Men", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://www.dirm.nord-atlantique-manche-ouest.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/livre-des-feux-r402.html", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "unit": "", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": "Fl(3) W 20s" }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "needs-verification", "date_precision": "day", "field_id": "automation_date", "field_label": "Automation date", "id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000045", "payload": { "claim_id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000045", "confidence": "needs-verification", "date_precision": "day", "field_id": "automation_date", "field_label": "Automation date", "raw_value": "Automation date noted in supplied research; keep as draft until confirmed against an official source line.", "review_status": "draft", "source_evidence": [ { "evidence_note": "Drafting input only.", "source_id": "local:research-docs", "source_label": "French lighthouse identity evolution research inputs", "source_type": "local_research_input", "source_url": "" } ], "source_id": "french-lighthouse-identity-evolution:research-docs", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "Draft lifecycle claim from supplied research documents; do not treat as accepted canonical fact until official confirmation is attached.", "source_title": "French Lighthouse Identity Evolution research inputs", "source_type": "local_research_input", "source_url": "", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "1990-04-10", "valid_to": "", "value": "1990-04-10" }, "raw_value": "Automation date noted in supplied research; keep as draft until confirmed against an official source line.", "record_status": "draft", "review_status": "draft", "source_id": "french-lighthouse-identity-evolution:research-docs", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "Draft lifecycle claim from supplied research documents; do not treat as accepted canonical fact until official confirmation is attached.", "source_quote": "", "source_title": "French Lighthouse Identity Evolution research inputs", "source_type": "local_research_input", "source_url": "", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "unit": "", "valid_from": "1990-04-10", "valid_to": "", "value": "1990-04-10" }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "needs-verification", "date_precision": "year", "field_id": "apparatus_change", "field_label": "Apparatus change", "id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000046", "payload": { "claim_id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000046", "confidence": "needs-verification", "date_precision": "year", "field_id": "apparatus_change", "field_label": "Apparatus change", "raw_value": "Mercury-bath replacement/restoration note from the supplied research and transcript.", "review_status": "draft", "source_evidence": [ { "evidence_note": "Drafting input only.", "source_id": "local:transcript", "source_label": "Video transcript and research inputs", "source_type": "local_research_input", "source_url": "" } ], "source_id": "french-lighthouse-identity-evolution:transcript", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "Draft identity-evolution claim retained for later apparatus/heritage-asset modeling.", "source_title": "Video transcript and research inputs", "source_type": "local_research_input", "source_url": "", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "2019", "valid_to": "", "value": "Mercury-bath support removed and replaced during restoration work." }, "raw_value": "Mercury-bath replacement/restoration note from the supplied research and transcript.", "record_status": "draft", "review_status": "draft", "source_id": "french-lighthouse-identity-evolution:transcript", "source_nid": 937, "source_note": "Draft identity-evolution claim retained for later apparatus/heritage-asset modeling.", "source_quote": "", "source_title": "Video transcript and research inputs", "source_type": "local_research_input", "source_url": "", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000249", "target_type": "lighthouse", "unit": "", "valid_from": "2019", "valid_to": "", "value": "Mercury-bath support removed and replaced during restoration work." }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "high", "date_precision": "year", "field_id": "heritage_status", "field_label": "Heritage status", "id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000047", "payload": { "claim_id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000047", "confidence": "high", "date_precision": "year", "field_id": "heritage_status", "field_label": "Heritage status", "raw_value": "Cordouan Lighthouse is represented as a UNESCO World Heritage property in official listing 1625.", "review_status": "accepted", "source_evidence": [ { "evidence_note": "Official World Heritage listing for Cordouan Lighthouse.", "source_id": "unesco:1625", "source_label": "Cordouan Lighthouse - UNESCO World Heritage Centre", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1625/" } ], "source_id": "unesco:1625", "source_note": "Accepted heritage-status claim for the draft Cordouan identity.", "source_title": "Cordouan Lighthouse - UNESCO World Heritage Centre", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1625/", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000618", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "2021", "valid_to": "", "value": "UNESCO World Heritage property" }, "raw_value": "Cordouan Lighthouse is represented as a UNESCO World Heritage property in official listing 1625.", "record_status": "accepted", "review_status": "accepted", "source_id": "unesco:1625", "source_nid": null, "source_note": "Accepted heritage-status claim for the draft Cordouan identity.", "source_quote": "", "source_title": "Cordouan Lighthouse - UNESCO World Heritage Centre", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1625/", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000618", "target_type": "lighthouse", "unit": "", "valid_from": "2021", "valid_to": "", "value": "UNESCO World Heritage property" }, { "claim_scope": "field", "confidence": "needs-verification", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "identity_note", "field_label": "Identity note", "id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000048", "payload": { "claim_id": "FIELD-CLAIM-000048", "confidence": "needs-verification", "date_precision": "", "field_id": "identity_note", "field_label": "Identity note", "raw_value": "Draft note from official La Coubre and POP references plus supplied story research.", "review_status": "draft", "source_evidence": [ { "evidence_note": "French Ministry of Culture heritage record for La Coubre.", "source_id": "pop:IA17008905", "source_label": "Phare de la Coubre - POP / Mérimée", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://www.pop.culture.gouv.fr/notice/merimee/IA17008905" }, { "evidence_note": "Official public history page for La Coubre.", "source_id": "pharedelacoubre:history", "source_label": "Phare de la Coubre - Un peu d'histoire", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://www.pharedelacoubre.fr/un-peu-d-histoire" } ], "source_id": "pop:IA17008905;pharedelacoubre:history", "source_note": "Draft note only; specific tower sequence should be modeled as dated claims after source-by-source review.", "source_title": "La Coubre official and POP references", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://www.pharedelacoubre.fr/un-peu-d-histoire", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000619", "target_type": "lighthouse", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": "Successive La Coubre towers are treated as a draft identity-evolution research topic pending field-level verification." }, "raw_value": "Draft note from official La Coubre and POP references plus supplied story research.", "record_status": "draft", "review_status": "draft", "source_id": "pop:IA17008905;pharedelacoubre:history", "source_nid": null, "source_note": "Draft note only; specific tower sequence should be modeled as dated claims after source-by-source review.", "source_quote": "", "source_title": "La Coubre official and POP references", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://www.pharedelacoubre.fr/un-peu-d-histoire", "target_id": "LUX-LH-000619", "target_type": "lighthouse", "unit": "", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "value": "Successive La Coubre towers are treated as a draft identity-evolution research topic pending field-level verification." } ], "conflicts": [], "evidence": [ { "note": "", "source_id": "french-lighthouse-identity-evolution:research-docs", "source_title": "French Lighthouse Identity Evolution research inputs", "source_type": "local_research_input", "source_url": "" }, { "note": "", "source_id": "french-lighthouse-identity-evolution:transcript", "source_title": "Video transcript and research inputs", "source_type": "local_research_input", "source_url": "" }, { "note": "", "source_id": "node:935", "source_title": "Petit Minou", "source_type": "migration_field", "source_url": "/node/935" }, { "note": "", "source_id": "unesco:1625", "source_title": "Cordouan Lighthouse - UNESCO World Heritage Centre", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1625/" }, { "note": "", "source_id": "pop:IA17008905;pharedelacoubre:history", "source_title": "La Coubre official and POP references", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://www.pharedelacoubre.fr/un-peu-d-histoire" }, { "note": "", "source_id": "dirm:livre-des-feux:ar-men", "source_title": "Livre des Feux - Ar-Men", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://www.dirm.nord-atlantique-manche-ouest.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/livre-des-feux-r402.html" }, { "note": "", "source_id": "pop:IA29000456", "source_title": "Phare d'Ar-Men - POP / Mérimée", "source_type": "official_reference", "source_url": "https://pop.culture.gouv.fr/notice/merimee/IA29000456" } ], "heritage_assets": [], "heritage_relations": [], "language": "en", "locations": [], "media": [], "open_question_details": [], "open_questions": [], "output_intents": [ "article", "notebooklm_pack", "podcast_2hosts", "audio_overview", "video_overview", "slides", "infographic" ], "status": "accepted", "story_id": "french-lighthouse-identity-evolution", "story_type": "light_group", "summary": "English-first article and story project built from the transcript and research notes around the thesis: the light is not the lighthouse; it is what survives the lighthouse.", "targets": [ { "id": "LUX-LH-000249", "kind": "lighthouse", "title": "Petit Minou", "url": "/node/935/" }, { "id": "LUX-LH-000618", "kind": "lighthouse", "title": "Cordouan Lighthouse", "url": "/lighthouses/LUX-LH-000618/" }, { "id": "LUX-LH-000619", "kind": "lighthouse", "title": "La Coubre Lighthouse", "url": "/lighthouses/LUX-LH-000619/" } ], "title": "The Light Is Not the Lighthouse", "warning_details": [], "warnings": [] }